Home  Interviews Bio Essays   Work   Pig magazine  Video   Heyoka Magazine ARTList
PART 1
PART 2
PART 3
PART 4
PART 5

 

Frequently asked questions

PART 2

 

Cartrain verses Damien Hirst

 

 

 

Q. What do you think about the young 16 year old British artist Cartrain, and Damien Hirst going after him for copyright abuse?
 
John LeKay: I do find the Cartrain incident very interesting, but not totally surprising.

Q. What was the first thought that came to you when you read about this?

JL: The first thing that came to mind was the obvious, meaning that he was projecting onto Cartrain what he himself has been accused of doing by other people.  Especially, after all the times that he himself has been sued for copyright infringement. .

Q. Do you think he made an error in doing this?

JL: I don't know, it may be within Damien's right to do this, but sometimes these things need to happen in order to see the bigger picture, or to be able to look at it from a different perspective. This is Damien's karma being played out.
 
The thing that does surprise me a little is that Cartrain used his work in graffiti based prints and in collage based works. He did not claim that he came up with this diamond skull idea or anything to that effect. He did not plagiarize it or copy it, or imitate it. He incorporated a photographic representation of it into one of his own original artworks.
 
It's a little odd because there is a 100 year old tradition in art in making satirical and critical based art work like this going back to the Dada movement and even before this to Picasso and Braque. I see this as a photographic digital based new media collage (from the French: coller, to glue).  One has to keep in mind that a traditional collage is made from an assemblage of different forms, thus creating a brand new whole. What Cartrain created in effect was something new.   

Therefore, a collage work may include newspaper clippings, bits of colored or hand-made papers, portions of other artwork, photographs  etc.,  glued to a piece of paper or canvas. These days new media artists do not just use glue but also achieve similar results using Photoshop. They cut and paste images and words and then also digitally paint on top of them. Actually, this type of satirical works goes back to a group called the Incoherents, even predating Marcel Duchamp's Fountain by 37 years. see here

 
Cartrain Big Issue Seller
 

Sherri Levines fountain after Duchamp

 

 
There is also a history of appropriation in art practiced by artists like Richard Prince, Sherri Levine, Jeff Koons and many others. I also find it pretty ironic that he would legally go after Cartrain to hand in his originals in order to have them destroyed.

Q: What would you do if someone did that to your work?

JL: You mean, like Cartrain's appropriating Damien's work? It's always easier to comment on other people than when it happens to you, but I think I would not pay it any mind or draw any more attention to it, but would just probably laugh about it. Once you see through all of this stuff you see how silly it all is.  More of the same Lila.

Continue to part 3

Back to Top